Education, Michigan Republicans — November 20, 2013 at 2:30 pm

Corporatist mission accomplished: charter schools strangling public schools


Who could have EVER seen this coming???

A downgrade of the bond ratings of 53 Michigan school districts is proving what charter school opponents have long warned against: charter schools are diminishing public schools’ ability to have stable budgets by siphoning off tax dollars into for-profit corporations.

Moody’s Investors Service made this move this week citing “significant fiscal strain related to charter enrollment growth”:

A growing number of Michigan school districts face higher borrowing costs after downgrades this year by Moody’s Investors Service, which cited financial pressure stemming from falling enrollment and charter school growth in a report issued Tuesday.

The bond rating agency said since January it downgraded 53 school districts in Michigan, nearly as many as in the previous two years combined.

Justin Marlowe, a professor at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee who has written about local government finance, said increased charter school competition and tight state budgets are squeezing the districts.

The “proliferation of charter schools and ongoing state budget problems have put more pressure on local school districts,” Marlowe said, adding there “don’t seem to be any immediate solutions unless we rethink how we finance school districts.”

According to the Moody’s report, 425 of the state’s 549 public school districts lost students between 2004 and 2012, with total enrollment slipping 13.2 percent.

But as overall enrollment was falling, charter schools were growing: They had 120,000 students in Michigan at the end of the last school year and the number of schools rose by 8 percent for this school year, to 298.

This is no accident. It’s a plan that’s been in place by those who wish to diminish the ability of teachers to bargain collectively for wages, benefits, and working conditions and to redirect tax dollars earmarked for educating our children into the coffers of for-profit charter school companies.

Michigan has nearly a quarter of the charter schools in the United States and roughly 80% of our charter schools are run by for-profit businesses. They frequently have access to school buildings at a fraction of the cost that public schools built them for and then hire non-unionized teachers to educate our kids on the cheap.

All along they’ve been aided and abetted by Michigan Republicans who have helped kneecap teachers unions and have encouraged the proliferation of charter schools since they took power in 2011. It’s plan hatched long ago and now it is playing out exactly as they planned. Rather than making solid investments in our kids and our educators, Republicans have slashed education budgets to the point where nearly 10% of our districts are now dealing with budget deficits. As they have done with our cities, Republicans cut the statewide budget and forced the pain down to the local level.

For a political party that claims to be about traditional American values like offering a good education to every child, they sure have a funny way of showing it.

  • Gloria Woods

    People who hold “traditional American values” must be those whose tradition has always included private schools for their children.

  • Martin Pollard

    My girlfriend works for Detroit Public Schools as a Head Start teacher. She knows first-hand the toll that charter schools have taken on public education (in addition to the all-around budget mismanagement that’s been a hallmark of DPS for ages). You’re right, it’s true Republicanism in action, and it’s absolutely shameful.

  • Sharon Douglas

    I have a really hard time believing this is legal. They are taking OUR tax dollars and giving them to private for profit schools.. Our taxes are to be for the publicly owned and controlled commons. Our schools, post offices, roads, prisons, libraries. And they TAKE the school buildings that WE paid for instead of paying for and building their own. How can people fall for this?? These are for profit corporations. the ONLY motive for them is to increase profits. And how do you accomplish that in a school setting?? You cut resources. Programs offered, books. computers, all supplies, and of course teachers salaries AND reduce teaching requirements.. It’s a race to the bottom. But they pay the top guy at K12 12 million in salary since ’09. ( think it was since ’09) People better hope for at least 2 things. One, that your children do not receive their education in a for profit school. And two, never make a mistake and be placed in a for profit prison. The first will ruin your future, the second will cost you their life. The right constantly demonizes and deliberately sabotage’s our commons to justify privatization. Where ever we have a big pile of tax payers money, they want it. Public Education, Social Security and our Defense budgets are slowly but surely being demonized and drained and handed over to Wall Street and Private for Profit Corporations.

  • Pingback: QOTD: Eclectablog Edition | Proud Liberal()

  • Pingback: Financial Report: Charter Schools Strangling Public Schools in Michigan | Diane Ravitch's blog()

  • Pingback: Special Report: Abolishing Representative Government Through Education - Capitol Hill Outsider()